Something interesting hit me a few days ago. I was using Google when I noticed the feature “Web History”. Basically, it’s all about saving your web history to Google so that you can access it at a later time. I’m sure that’s an awesome feature, but I instantly got struck by the big “No No No…” which lead to this post.
Most of the people reading this are Google users. I’m a big time Google fan. To be honest, I’m having a hard time trying to remember how I were able to browse the Internet effectively before Google. Their search engine is excellent, the notebook is handy, the online office productivity suite is not so bad either, gMail leaves a bit to wish for but it’s innovative and useful, Google Maps and Google Earth fills the voids that are left since geography class, and there’s of course Google Video and YouTube not to mention Google Groups. It’s fancy, that’s for sure.
What’s even better is that you have one single log in for all these services. Or, is it? If we just let our thoughts run wild here for a bit we realize that with one unique key (john.doe@gmail.com) we can access a persons e-mail account. The same unique key now gives us access to John’s Internet history so we know what web pages he has browsed. John’s spreadsheets and word processor documents are also available using the same identical key, linking them to the previously accessed Internet history as well as e-mail communications. Basically, you have got one key that unlocks a truckload of data about yourself, and you’re putting all this information in the hands of Google.
The “Evil Villain” problem (a.k.a Big Brother Symptom)
Please note that this scenario is not based on the fact that the information holder is evil, but more that the information is present and so are the tools to access it, but I’m gonna go “all in” here in honor of the post title. Just remember that what I’m writing here is not facts, it’s merely a mind play to help you think in a way that’s a bit more aware. In my opinion, there is a difference between awareness and paranoia, and when it comes to this topic I’m just being aware of the risks.
Now, imagine if Google was not at all formed in a garage back in 1998 by two college kids. Google was formed by two agents from the CIA, and it’s been government funded ever since. After a slow start it’s now become more or less every man’s online office. All the information you store as well as your browsing habits and your e-mail/im communications is accessible to you, but also to the people that are in control of the country’s intelligence agency. It might be a bit far fetched, and as I said it’s not based on any facts, but it still leaves one huge question unanswered: Who is really in control of your data?
What this all boils down to is trust. When you link information like this, it’s all about trust. The same question is valid for Yahoo, MSN, and all the other major actors who all offer a “one size fits all”-solution with e-mail, instant messaging, and a huge bundle of other Internet-related services. If you don’t trust the website, look for alternatives or register using incomplete details. Your online bookmarking site perhaps doesn’t need to know your full name or your address for example, while your favorite e-commerce site doesn’t really need to know if you’re married or single.
Sure, the purpose may be purely statistical, but don’t give a web site that you doesn’t trust any information that you would not give a stranger on the street. This is also related to the next scenario, which I’ve decided to call…
Data-leak
…which is a pretty wide term. Leaking of data could be either intentional or unintentional but could in either way compromise security or cause harm. Doing a simple Google search on the topic renders a number of hits, such as “AT&T online store hacked for credit card info”, “Steam Hacked, Credit Card Numbers Taken”, and “T.J. Maxx hack exposes consumer data”.
Credit Card data is probably the most sensitive information that could be leaked. The cards them self are based on more or less ancient technology (magnetic strip) and lack proper security. But other information may also be just as sensitive. Perhaps you wouldn’t like people to go over your web searches, history, or e-mail even if you have got nothing to hide.
Intentional data leak is for example having your e-mail address listed in plain text on your profile page for anyone to see. I won’t cover this too closely, since you’re probably already aware of this risk. You usually browse around on for example a social networking website before registering so you know what to expect. The unintentional leak is what’s more important, and also to know what’s at risk.
Hacking Google!
You know that co-worker that just seems to totally hate you? The guy that goes through your trash can in order to find something to report to your boss? Imagine if that co-worker managed to figure out your Google account details. Within a minute he would have in his hand every search you’ve ever made, which could be very compromising when taken out of context. He would also as previously mentioned have access to your browsing history and your e-mail.
Your single key, that is there only to simplify things for you, have now opened up the entire vault of your private life to someone that should not have access to it. With one single authentication token he can now access every little piece of information there is about your “online life”. Not really a nice scenario.
What to do then?
I covered passwords and online personas in the last post, so read that if you haven’t already. Personally, I don’t use Google or Yahoo for all my online business. I use Yahoo’s web based e-mail, I use Googles web-search, and I have a totally different user account at YouTube. None of the three sites share the same authentication data.
As always, this is a matter of trust. Who do you trust? I’ve chosen to trust my OpenID providers (I currently use two different providers), and I’ve chosen to trust Yahoo to keep my e-mail safe.
Who you trust is up to you. Just remember to think twice before sacrificing integrity or security for convenience.
A final note
I have made sure to write this through the article, but it can’t be stressed enough that Google is not an evil CIA corporation that’s trying to steal your identity. This article just used Google as an example, and you can safely go on using it without worrying. This article is not about Google or any other online service provider, but rather about awareness. This is also valid for Yahoo, YouTube or any other name mentioned here.
